Main Content

Property

Saint Augustine, FL 32084 23 Nelmar Ave

23 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 123 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 223 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 3
62 more
23 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 423 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 523 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 623 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 723 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 823 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 923 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 1023 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 1123 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 1223 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 1323 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 1423 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 1523 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 1623 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 1723 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 1823 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 1923 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 2023 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 2123 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 2223 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 2323 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 2423 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 2523 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 2623 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 2723 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 2823 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 2923 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 3023 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 3123 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 3223 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 3323 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 3423 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 3523 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 3623 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 3723 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 3823 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 3923 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 4023 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 4123 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 4223 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 4323 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 4423 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 4523 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 4623 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 4723 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 4823 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 4923 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 5023 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 5123 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 5223 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 5323 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 5423 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 5523 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 5623 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 5723 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 5823 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 5923 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 6023 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 6123 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 6223 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 6323 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 6423 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 6523 Nelmar Ave Saint Augustine, FL - Image 66
Presented By: Berkshire Hathaway Homeservices Florida Network Realty
  • MLS# 251596
  • 03/21/2025
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 3
  • Full/Half Baths • 2 / 1
  • SQFT • 2,456

Home Details

Step into a century of elegance with this exquisite 100-year-old Dutch Colonial home, nestled in the heart of St. Augustine’s most distinguished historic neighborhood. A rare offering, this architectural gem is being sold for only the second time in its storied history, a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for those who appreciate the craftsmanship and grandeur of a bygone era. Built in 1926, this home is a true treasure, seamlessly blending original charm with modern luxury. Surrounded by majestic oaks, stately palms, vibrant azaleas, and lush pecan trees, it sits in a postcard-perfect setting, evoking the beauty and grace of a historic estate. From the moment you step through the grand entryway, you’re transported to another era. Soaring ceilings, an elegant staircase, and stunning original leaded glass details create an atmosphere of refinement, while the warmth of original hardwood floors, a stately fireplace, and vintage light fixtures whispers of the home’s enduring legacy. Yet, while history is carefully preserved, this home has been meticulously updated for effortless modern living. A brand-new kitchen with premium finishes, designer bathrooms, and an added charming powder room on the main floor provide contemporary comfort while complementing the home’s classic style. Recent electrical, plumbing, AC, and roof updates ensure that this historic treasure stays in impeccable condition. Beyond its elegant main living areas, the home offers serene spaces to unwind, create, and entertain. The first-floor sunroom, adorned with original French doors and a sliding door to the porch, overlooks a picturesque firepit and lush azalea and palm garden, an idyllic retreat for morning coffee or evening relaxation. Separately, a covered porch off the kitchen provides a charming space for afternoon tea or al fresco dining, allowing you to enjoy the beauty of nature in comfort. Upstairs, the expansive primary bedroom is a true sanctuary-spacious enough to waltz around in, with five large windows framing breathtaking views of the trees and sunlight. The atmosphere is so tranquil, it almost feels as if you are floating inside a natural cloud, enveloped by light and greenery. Another bonus room, once used as a "sleeping room" before air conditioning era, offers flexible space bathed in natural light, perfect for a study, art studio, or reading nook. Located in Nelmar Terrace, a National Register Historic District, this home is surrounded by some of St. Augustine’s most distinguished residences. Tree-lined sidewalks, friendly neighbors, and an intimate sense of community create a truly special place, one where history and modern life blend seamlessly. Unlike other historic districts, Nelmar Terrace remains private and peaceful, offering a retreat from the tourist bustle while still placing you at the heart of the city’s vibrant culture. With a waterfront pocket park just steps away, Vilano Beach only 5 minutes away, and downtown St. Augustine’s historic charm at your fingertips, this home is more than a residence, it’s an invitation to become a steward of history while living in unparalleled comfort. The detached 2-car garage features an upper-level bonus room with full electricity. The new fence has been thoughtfully positioned within the backyard, creating additional parking space in the alleyway. The original 100-year-old house plans, designed by renowned architect Fred A. Henderich, will be passed to the new owner, preserving a significant piece of architectural history. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a landmark home in Nelmar Terrace. Schedule your private showing today.
Presented By: Berkshire Hathaway Homeservices Florida Network Realty

Interior Features for 23 Nelmar Ave

Bedrooms

Beds3

Other Interior Features

FlooringTile, Wood

Other Rooms

Dining RoomFormal
Dining Room Length15
Dining Room Width13

General for 23 Nelmar Ave

Area03
Bank/Corporate Owned?No
ClassRESIDENTIAL
Elementary SchoolKetterlinus Elementary
ExtrasFireplace
Full Baths2
Half Baths1
HeatingElectric
High SchoolSt. Augustine High
Legal Description2-1 NELMAR TERRACE LOT 48 & W6FT OF LOT 49 OR4874/1891
Middle SchoolSebastian Middle
New Construction Y/NNo
Price Per Sq Ft Total AG447.88
StatusActive
StatusContingent
Stories2
StyleHistoric
SubdivisionNelmar Terrace
Taxes$1,821
TypeSingle Family Residence
WaterCity
Year Built1926

Exterior for 23 Nelmar Ave

Acreage1/4 to 1/2 Acre
DockNo
Lot DimensionsRegular
Lot Size Area0.29
WaterfrontNo

Additional Details

Price History

Schools

Elementary School Ketterlinus Elementary
Middle School Sebastian Middle
High School St. Augustine High

Sheila K Jerome

Realtor
Price $1,100,000
MLS#251596
List Date 03/21/2025
Property Type Contingent
Phone 786.282.8282
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 23 Nelmar Ave

Get In Touch

Contact Us
Keep up to date with the latest market trends and opportunities in Jacksonville.

    Skip to content